Ye Ole Fashioned Ice Cream & Sandwich Cafe

Isabel Brown

3 weeks ago •

My little pregnant self was craving a root beer float so we randomly stopped in and had a great experience. The BLT was delicious and literally was a whole pack of bacon. My husband loved his cheeseburger. I got a root beer float that was amazing and came with extra root beer. Both my husband and son enjoyed their ice cream (chocolate and crazy cookie dough). Lindsay and the staff were all so kind to us and continued to check on us throughout our time there. So happy we stopped in!!

margaret mccommon

2 months ago •

I had lunch with a friend and her 1yr old daughter and the servers were very helpful and friendly! While we were there a lady came in with about (8)?? children who were unruly! They didn't buy anything but just wanted samples of all icecream!!! I was so impressed with the smiles and kindness and patience of the servers! They were great! I would highly recommend this site to everyone! The food was great with oversize servings. It was my friend's first time there, and she said she would definitely come back!

Lynn Jones

a month ago •

I ordered a strawberry sundae that I can only describe as dry and very wrong! It was made with ice cream, banana, and strawberries and absolutely no strawberry syrup. I didn't order it with banana. Unfortunately, I was dealing with a problem and didn't watch them make it like I normally would. When I got home and removed it from the bag I was extremely disappointed. When I followed up I was to told "That's how we make them now." I've been going there for years and never had a bad experience. They definitely need to go back to the old correct way of making strawberry sundaes and ditch the dry nightmare.

Sarah Worel

a month ago •

I came in ten minutes before closing, which I know is annoying, believe me. We were left right as they closed. But the guy who served us was very rude. He had long purple braids that were not pulled back in a net. Because we were so late, I was being so sweet asking how he was doing and thanking him over and over. I got very rude passive aggressive responses. Then, he started making the Sundae after touching his hair and the money I gave him. He started cutting up the bananas with no gloves on, obviously spreading any germs. He saw my friend looking at him and then he put on gloves afterwards. But the bananas remained in my sundae. I spent $15 on ice cream I won’t eat. I also tipped him before he made the sundae because I felt so bad coming in late. Extremely frustrating experience. I understand it’s annoying to come in right before closing but we certainly did not deserve that.

Micah Freeman

2 weeks ago •

This lives up to is name with the old fashioned ice cream vibe. The ice cream is served in generous portions. The ice cream is very creamy with plenty of the mix in. I had the brownie s'mores which was delicious. I find a small waffle cone is plenty to satisfy my ice cream craving. I plan on returning many times.