The Upper Crust

Michael J. Metzger

2 months ago •

The Upper Crust. My family and I have been here twice now, and both times, we were extremely impressed with the pizza. It is so flavorful with just the right amount of toppings and the way it's cooked to perfection in the wood fired ovens, which just adds to the taste. The staff is very attentive and friendly, and both times that we have been our food came out in a very timely fashion after making our order. The restaurant also has two bars, plenty of seating, is very family friendly with a plethora of games to play in the back of the restaurant as well. As long as the food stays good and the awesome service continues, I definitely see us becoming regulars here whenever we are in Gettysburg. The only issue that would come to mind was the parking, which didn't bother us because we didn't mind the walk from the parking garage, but it can especially become an issue when Gettysburg is busy or there are any special events going on. That being said , I definitely suggest that you give it a try.

Laura Williams

a month ago •

While walking around Gettysburg, we stumbled upon an amazing restaurant called the Upper Crust. This restaurant is connected to two other places: a BBQ joint and an ice cream parlor. You can order from all three places while dining inside the Upper Crust. The inside of the restaurant is huge and has skee ball and pool tables in the back. The front of the restaurant is open, allowing you to enjoy the beautiful weather outside. We tried the sweet and spicy pizza, and it was absolutely delicious! The crust was perfectly crunchy, and the flavors were fantastic. The strawberry margarita was made from scratch and was really tasty! We sat at the bar, and the bartender was very attentive and hardworking. Overall, it was a perfect 10/10 experience, and I can't wait to go back and try more items

Tamal Chakraborty

a month ago •

I mean it was okay pizza .. the brisket pizza was a bad idea as the brisket gets dry and burnt and not enough to be honest for the price ..the dough seems good but the crust were uneven some thin some thick . The sauce was not needed ruined the entire pizza but we were starving as yiu can see so yeah for the locations and service I would recommend. The chicken tangy and sweet smoked wings were actually good and moist ... quality if the meat seemed store bought but did not seem frozen to me...overall ambience ans service was good. Good for a quick bite and a beer !

Patrick Christopher

2 months ago •

Phenomenal experience. The vibes are high, the room is spacious, the staff is welcoming and friendly, and the food is delish. Brought a tour bus of students and we were quickly accommodated with hot pizza and great service. The gaming area is awesome, and the kids had a blast after dinner. Got to enjoy dinner and play pool with my students in a great atmosphere in downtown Gettysburg. Can’t beat that. Thank you so much, Upper Crust!

josh good

a week ago •

I went there with a group of eight now the place wasn't busy but it still took over an hour for any of us to get a meal. Wish we just would have gotten up and walked out. Portion sizes were insanely small food is mediocre at best and service could learn how to count just saying The price of the mediocre food was extraordinarily high for what was given will never go back there