I Love New York Pizza

Kyle Phillips

3 weeks ago •

Honestly, this place is a hole in the wall. But it's a convenient location and it's the pizza that counts right? As far as pizza places go in this area, these guys make one of the best pies I've had. They've been cranking the most consistent pies out of this location for as long as I can remember. I'm pretty sure they've had the same guys in the back slinging pizzas for years. Total naturals

Justin & Sarah Matteson

2 years ago •

The stromboli here was delicious.

drketchup1988

a month ago •

Have had pizza there before and it was good. This time, pizza was extremely dry, barely any sauce. Called bc we were delivered edible cardboard and the owner (?) said that he always puts the same amount (1 scoop of sauce) on every pizza without listening to anything else said when trying to explain this is not what we’ve had in the past. Told we’d have to order extra sauce, and pay for it, if we wanted more. We’ve had this pizza before and never needed to order extra sauce.

Bonnie Osborn

a month ago •

LARGE variety of pizzas with various combinations of toppings ready and waiting for you! There must have been 15 different pizza options for slice selections - thin and sicilian. Mix and match!! I just wanted cheese, it was fresh and hot out of the oven. Fast, friendly & reasonable!

Ashley Kayser

a month ago •

I placed an online order and there was a mistake that I realized after I cashed out. I call the pizza shop asking them to correct it fully willing to pay the difference. They refused to correct my order and referred me to call the online ordering company. I did so, paid the difference And then waited an hour for my hour. All to have it delivered with the original error. When I called the shop again they refused to take any responsibility or offer resolution. They officially lost a customer over a $2 topping. Terrible customer service extremely slow delivery (I live on the same road)